China’s Belt and Road Initiative Dominance or Development: What is the American Response

Document Type : Original Article


lecturer at Islamic Azad university, Rafsanjan, Iran


Chinas` ambitious Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has attracted the eye of the many economists worldwide. Many of these economists believe that the Belt and Road Initiative is part of China’s vision of a world where America will no longer be the dominant superpower. It is possible that this may be true. China has committed an outsized chunk of its resources towards this project. More than $1 trillion worth of investments are poured into projects which are directly or indirectly associated with the Belt and Road Initiative. the question is of what else the U.S should do if it’s serious about countering Chinese influence.? Will the developing world fall under China’s sway? whether the U.S should worry about the economic and political influence these projects may bring for China? This paper to both identify areas of common interest and possible cooperation, also as shed light on areas of disagreement that need further work.


Main Subjects

Article Title [فارسی]

ابتکار کمربند جاده چین تسلط یا توسعه: پاسخ آمریکا چیست

Author [فارسی]

  • قدرت الله بهبودی نژاد
Al Jazeera, 2019. ‘China’s Silk Road Project: A trap or an opportunity?’, (17 May 2017). retrieved: 20 June 2019. available at: opinion/2017/05/china-silk-road-project-trap-opportunity-170514142652061.html.
AY, Chang. 2016. “China's rise and its evolutionary narrative of core interest (1980-2016): An analysis from the perspective of power structure transition”. China Research, 61.
Anthony R. 2018. ‘China’s BRI Could Be Administrative Nightmare,’ Nikkei Asian Review, October 31, 2017, retrieved 6 march 2018, available at: https://asia.nikkei. com/ Opinion/China-s-BRI-could-be-administrative-nightmare2.
Asian Development Bank.2019. ‘Asian Infrastructure Needs Exceed $1.7 Trillion Per Year, Double Previous Estimates”, February 28, 2017, retrieved march 2019, available at: https:// www. adb. org/ news/ asia- infrastructure- needs- exceed- 17-trillion- year-double-previous-estimates.
Ben Blanchard.2017. ‘China Grants Economic Aid to Djibouti, Site of Overseas Military Base’, Reuters, November23, 2017, retrieved August  10, 2019, available at: djibouti/china-grants-economic-aid-todjibouti-site-of-overseas-military-base idUSKBN1DN126.htm.
Beauchamp, Mustafa .2015. N ‘Dispatch from Beijing: PLA Writings on the New Silk Road’ China Brief Vol. 15(4): 1-3.
Blackwell, R. D. and Harris, J. M. 2016. “The lost art of economic statecraft: Restoring an American tradition”. Foreign Affairs, 95(2), 99–110.
Calabrese J. 2018.China’s One Belt, One Road (OBOR) Initiative: Envisioning Iran’s Role, in: China’s Presence in the Middle East: The Implications of the One Belt, One Road Initiative, (eds.) A. Ehteshami, N. Horesh, Routledge, Abingdon.
Clifford, C. 2017. ‘China’s One Belt, One Road: Challenges and Opportunities – Thought Leadership’, 2017, retrieved August 10, 2019, available at:https:// www.
Carnegie Endowment, 2017. ‘Carnegie Experts on the Belt and Road Initiative and Forum,’ Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, May 11, 2017, retrieved April 10, 2019, available at: htm.
Chatzky, Andrew and McBride, J. 2018. ‘China’s Massive Belt and Road Initiative” retrieved August 10, 2019, available at:
Chance, Alek.2017. ‘The Belt and Road Initiative and the Future of Globalization’, the diplomat, retrieved July 11, 2019, available at:https:// 2017/10/the-belt-and-road-initiative-and-the-future-of-globalization/.
Cecilia J. Perez and Derek Scissors .2018. ‘The Chinese State Funds Belt and Road but Does Not Have Trillions to Spare’, American Enterprise Institute, March 28, 2018, retrieved April 5, 2019, available at:
Deloitte .2018. ‘Embracing the BRI ecosystem in 2018’, 12 February 2018, retrieved 30 July 2018, available at: https:// www2. deloitte. com/content/dam/insights/ us/ articles/ 4406_Belt-and-road-initiative/4406_Embracing-the-BRI-ecosystem.pdf.
Djankov, S and Miner, S et al .2019. ‘China’s Belt and Road Initiative: Motives, Scope and Challenges’ Peterson Institute for International Economics, retrieved April 2019,
David, Brewster .2018. ‘should the united states be worried about china’s belt and road initiative? ‘March 2018, retrieved 5 may 2019, available at: https://www.ussc. analysis/ the- debate- papers-should-the-united-states-be-worried-about-chinas-belt-and-road-initiative html.
David, Brewster .2018b. ‘Welcome to the New Indian Ocean’ The Diplomat, 21 February 2018, retrieved 21 March 2019 available at: 2018/02/ welcome-to-the-new-indian-ocean/htm.
Faruqee Hamid, and S. Berkmen .2016. ‘The Regional Economic Outlook: Western Hemisphere – Managing Transitions and Risks, ’International Monetary Fund World Economic and Financial Surveys, April 2016, available at: https:// www.
Fallon T .2015. ‘The New Silk Road: Xi Jinping’s Grand Strategy for Eurasia’ American Foreign Policy Interests2015, Vol. 37(3): p. 146.
Fiedler R. 2016. Present and Potential Factors Destabilizing Central Asia as a Challenge to the European Union, “Przeglad Politologiczny”, Vol. 21, No. 2.
Gjon Borici.2018. ‘China's One Belt and One Road Initiative: The Response to Western Globalization?’ Germany and Illyria College, Pristina, Kosovo February 21,2018, retrieved January 2020ived January 2020 php/ iir/article/view/399.
Grossman, Derek.2020. The Quad Is Poised to Become Openly Anti-China Soon”
Hart, E, and Gewirtz.2018. ‘Asia-Pacific Security Issues in the U.S.-China Relationship,’ p.51.
Hurley, Morris, and Gailyn Porte .2018. ‘Examining the Debt Implications of the Belt and Road Initiative from a Policy Perspective’, retrieved 20 July 2018, available at:
Ikenberry, John and Darren J. Lim.2017. ‘China’s Emerging Institutional Statecraft, The Brookings Institution, April 2017, retrieved April 1,2018, available at: https:// www. content/uploads/2017/04/chinas-emerging-institutional-statecraft.pdf.
Joel, W .2018. ‘Securing China’s Belt and Road Initiative: Dimensions and Implications’, 20 June 2018, retrieved 1 February 2020, available at at: https:// 23.pdf
Kapstein, Ethan, shapiro, N.2018. ‘How Washington can beat Beijing’s global influence campaign’, Foreign Policy,11Jully 2018, retrieved January 2020 available at: htm.
Kelley, Danielle .2020. "China's Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank Challenges the Western-Dominated Status Quo," Charged Affairs, February 26, 2019, retrieved 1 January 2020,
Kendall, Andrea and David S. 2018. ‘How Russia and China Undermine Democracy,’ Foreign Affairs, October 2, 2018, retrieved may 2019, available at: https:// www.
Lin, D 2019. ‘The One Belt One Road Project and China's Foreign Relations ’Carter Center, available at:
Matthias L. and Jason Lange .2015. ‘U.S. Urges Allies to Think Twice Before Joining China-led Bank’, Reuters, March 17, 2015, available at: https:// www. reuters. com/ article/ us- europe- asia- bank/ u-s-urgesallies-to-think-twice-before-joining-china-led-bank.
Max, Greenwood, 2018. ‘Pompeo to Unveil Investment Push in Indo-Pacific, ’ The Hill, July 30, 2018,
McKinsey and Company .2016. ‘China’s One Belt, One Road: Will it reshape global trade?’, July 2016, retrived16 July 2019, available at: com/featured-insights/china/chinas-one-belt-one-road-will-it-reshape-global-trade.
Mehra Jyotsna .2020. The Australia-India-Japan-US Quadrilateral: Dissecting the China Factor”, https:// www. orfonline. org/ research/ the- australia- india- japan- us- quadrilateral/.
Prachi Juneja .2019. “America’s Response to China’s Belt and Road Initiative’, Management study guide, retrieved 7 July 2019, available at: https://www.
Poulsen and Bjerre .2017. Here we see the future: The Obama administration's pivot to Asia. In A. Edward, & J. Dumbrell (Eds.), Obama Presidency and the Politics of Change (pp. 307-327). Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan. available at:
Ratner, Ely congress report on China .2018. ‘Geostrategic and Military Drivers and Implications of the Belt and Road Initiative, retrieved March 18, 2018,
Rolland. 2017. ‘Chinas Eurasian Century: Political and Strategic Implications of the Belt and Road Initiative’, pp.195.
Rolland, N .2018. ‘China’s New Silk Road’ National Bureau of Asian Research, retrieved 23 June 2018).
Roy, Chowdhury .2018. ‘China a pillar of strength in Qatar’s fightback against Arab blockade,’ South China Morning Post, 9 June 2018.
Schuster, Simon M.2018. ‘The Future Is Asian: Commerce, Conflict, and Culture in the 21st Century’, February 15, 2018, retrieved 2 January 2020 https://www.
State Council Information Office.2015. ‘China’s Military Strategy,’ State Council Information Office, May 26, 2015, retrieved accessed 20 March 2019, available at:,ish/china/2015-05/26/c_134271001.htm.
Swaine, M .2014. ‘Chinese Views and Commentary on Periphery Diplomacy’ China Leadership Monitor, Vol. 44 pp. 1-43.
Tamkin Emily and Robbie Gramer 2017. ‘Tiller son Knocks China, Courts India Ahead of South Asia Trip, ’The Cable (blog), Foreign Policy, October 18, 2017, retrived11 November 2019, available at: https:// foreignpolicy. com/ 2017/10/18/tillerson-knocks-china-courts-india-ahead-of-south-asia-trip/.
U.S. Energy Information Administration 2015. “China Overview”, May 14, 2015, Retrieved 2 march 2019,
Varma, KJM .2018. ‘Xi Defends BRI: Says China Has No Geo-Political Calculations,’ Business World, April 10, 2018, retrieved 2 February 2020 article/Xi-defends-BRI-says-China-has-no-geo-political-calculations/10-04-2018-145937/.
Wang, Jessi .2012. ‘March West,’ China’s Geostrategic Rebalance’, Global Times, October 17, 2012, retrieved 24 september2019 opinion_world/2012-10/3193760.html.
Washington, O and Manning, R.2018. ‘Shaping the Asia-Pacific Future: Strengthening the Institutional Architecture for an Open, Rules-Based Economic Order’, Atlantic Council, available at: http://www.
Wuthnow .2018. “Securing China’s Belt and Road Initiative: Dimensions and Implications”, Institute for National Strategic Studies, U.S. National Defense University, January 25, 2018, available at: files/Wuthnow_USCC Testimony_20180123.pdf.
Ye Yu .2018. ‘China’s response to Belt and Road backlash,’ East Asia Forum, December 15, 2018, retrieved 11 October 2019, available at: https://www.