Threat Perceptions and Security Dilemma in the Middle East

Document Type : Original Article

Author

associate professor in the Department of International Relations

Abstract

There has been an almost unprecedented degree of hostility and hostile rhetorical exchanges during the last few years among major regional actors in the Middle East. Many observers are concerned about the formation of an escalating security dilemma in the region with unintended and/or unpredictable consequences. This article seeks to explain the current security dilemma in the region on the basis of the threat perceptions of three major regional actors, i.e., Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey2 , and the way in which their attempts for constituting a balance against each other may either lead to more problems in the region or less tensions. It will demonstrate how any act by the actors out of defensive concerns might be interpreted by others as an offensive approach. Yet it is suggested that through dialogue and confidence building measures much of the distrust and uncertainties can be overcome.

Keywords


Article Title [فارسی]

ادراکات از تهدید و معمای امنیتی در خاورمیانه

Author [فارسی]

  • حمیرا مشیرزاده

Keywords [فارسی]

  • مناقشات خاورمیانه
  • موازنه قوای منطقه ای
  • معمای امنیتی
  • ایران
  • عربستان سعودی
  • ترکیه
Al-Faisal, Turki (2013) “Saudi Arabia’s Foreign Policy,” Middle East Policy 10, 4.
Al-Rasheed, Madawi (2002) A History of Saudi Arabia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Aras, Bülent (2009) Davutoğlu Era in Turkish Foreign Policy. Ankara: SETA Policy Brief, 32.
Aras, Bulent and Rabia Karakaya Polat (2008) “From Conflict to Cooperation: Desecuritization of Turkey's Relations with Syria and Iran,” Security Dialogue 39: 495-515.
Asriran (1396 [2017)) “Ravabet Iran va Arabestan dar Gozar Tarikh (Iran-Saudi Relations in the Course of History,” available at: http://www.asriran.com/ fa/news/585653/%D8%B1%D9%88 %D8%A7% D8%A8% D8% B7-%D8%A7%
Athari, S.A., R.Hajimineh, and A. Enayati Shabkolaei (1392 [2013]) “A Comparative Study of Iran and Turkey’s Approaches to Middle East Developments,” Islamic World Political Investigations Quarterly 3,4: 1-25.
Aydin, Mustafa (1999) “Determinants of Turkish Foreign Policy: Historical Framework and Traditional Inputs,” Middle Eastern Studies 35, 4
Ayoob, Mohammad (2002) “Inequality and Theorizing in International Relations: The Case for Subaltern Realism,” International Studies Review 4, 3: 27-48.
Azimzadeh Ardabili, M. M., H. Masoudnia, and S.J.Emamjomezadeh (1396 [2017]) “New Turkish Foreign Policy and Competition with Iran,” International Relations Studies Quarterly 38: 95-128.
Barzegar, Kayhan (2005) “Understanding the Roots of Iranian Foreign Policy in the New Iraq,” Middle East Policy12, 2: 49-57.
Barzegar, Kayhan (2008) “Iran and the Shi’ite Crescent: Myths and Realities,” Brown Journal of World Affairs 15, 1: 87-99.
Barzegar, Kayhan (2010) “Iran’s Foreign Policy Strategy after Saddam,” Washington Quarterly 33,1: 173-189.
Bayar, Tuğba (2018) “Multiple Dualities: Seeking the Patterns in Iran’s Foreign Policy,” All Azimuth 0, 0: 1-18,
Bongers, Rob (2012-13) “Iran’s Foreign Policy Post-Invasion Iraq,” Journal of Politics & International Studies, 8: 124-160.
Cockburn, Patrick (2016) “Prince Mohammed bin Salman: Naïve, Arrogant Saudi Prince Is Playing with Fire,” The Independent available at: https:// www. independent. co.uk/ news/world/middle-east/prince-mohammed-bin-salman-naive-arrogant-saudi-prince-is-playing-with-fire-a6804481.html
Davutoğlu, Ahmet (2008) “Foreign Policy Vision: An Assessment of 2007,” Insight Turkey 10, 1: 77-96.
Doran, Michael Scott (2004) “The Saudi Paradox,” Foreign Affairs 83, 1: 35-51.
Drollette, Dan, Jr. (2016) “View from the Inside: Prince Turki al-Faisal on Saudi Arabia, Nuclear Energy and Weapons, and Middle East Politics,” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 72:1: 16-24.
Ennis, Crystal A. and Bessma Momani (2013) “Shaping the Middle East in the Midst of the Arab Uprisings: Turkish and Saudi Foreign Policy Strategies,” Third World Quarterly 34, 6: 1127–1144.
Forouzan, Y. and A. Alishahi (2018) “Study of Iran-Saudi Relations in the Persian Gulf Region within the Framework of the Threat Balance,” Journal of Political Sciences & Public Affairs 6, 1:
Friedman, Uri (2016) “What’s the Saudi-Iran Feud Really About? The Sunni-Shiite divide doesn’t explain it, according to one expert.” Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/01/iran-saudi-sunni-shiite/422808/.
Hacke, Christian and Jana Puglierin (2007) “John Hertz: Balancing Utopia and Reality,” International Relations 21, 3: 367-382.
Herz, John H. (1950) “Idealist Internationalism and the Security Dilemma,” World Politics 2, 2: 157-180.
Hopf, Ted (1998) “The Promise of Constructivism in International Relations Theory,” International Security 23, 1: 171-200.
Inbar, Efraim (2006) “The Need to Block a Nuclear Iran,” Middle East Review of International Affairs 10, 1: 85-104.
Jervis, Robert (1976) Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Jones, Peter (1998) “Iran’s Threat Perceptions and Arms Control Policies,” The Nonproliferation Review
Juneau, Thomas (2014) “Iran under Rouhani: Still Alone in the World,” Middle East Policy 11, 4: 92-.
Kamrava, Mehran (2013) “Mediation and Saudi Foreign Policy,” Orbis 58:1-19.
Kooshki, M. S. and E. Kiani (1394 [2015]) “Security Competitions of Iran and Turkey in the Course of Islamic Awakening in Egypt and Tunisia,” Contemporary Research on the Islamic Revolution 1, 1: 111-127.
Kirisci, Kemal (2004) “The Kurdish Question and Turkish Foreign Policy,” in L. G. Martin and D. Keredis, eds., The Future of Turkish Foreign Policy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Leverett, Flynt and Hillary Mann Leverett (2011) “The Arab Spring and the Saudi Counter- Revolution, Monthly Review Online availbale at: https://mronline.org/ 2011/04/16/the- arab- spring- and- the-saudi- counter-revolution/. (Last Access 9/21/2018)
Lynch, Marc (2016) “Why It’s Wrong to Say that the Arab Uprisings Failed,” Washington Post (March 28).
Mabon, Simon (2020) “The Kingdom and the Glory? Saudi Arabia as a Middle Power in the Contemporary Middle East,” in Adham Saouli, ed., Unfulfilled Aspirations: Middle Power Politics in the Middle East. New York: Oxford University Press: 135-156.
Martin, Lenore G.  (2004) “Turkey’s Middle East Foreign Policy,” in L. G. Martin and D. Keredis, eds., The Future of Turkish Foreign Policy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Mosallanezhad, Abbas (1395 [2016]) “Regional Balancing in Iran-Saudi Relations,” Journal of Politics 46, 4: 1067-1087.
Moshirzadeh, Homeira (2007) “Discursive Foundations of Iran’s Nuclear Policy,” Security Dialogue 38, 4:521-543.
Moshirzadeh, Homeira (2010) “Domestic Ideational Sources of Iran’s Foreign Policy,” Iranian Review of Foreign Affairs 1, 1: 153-192.
Mufti, Malik, (1998) “Daring and Caution in Turkish Foreign Policy,” The Middle East Journal 52, 1: 32-50.
Murinson, Alexander (2006) “The Strategic Depth Doctrine of Turkish Foreign Policy,” Middle Eastern Studies, 42, 6: 945 – 964.
Nonneman, Gerd (2005) “Determinants and Patterns of Saudi Foreign Policy: ‘Omnibalancing’ and ‘Relative Autonomy’ in Multiple Environments,” in P. Aarts and G. Nonneman, eds., Saudi Arabia in the Balance: Political Economy, Society, Foreign Affairs. London: Hus=rst and Company.
Peterson, J. E. (2002) Saudi Arabia and the Illusion of Security. Adelphi Papers 348. London and New York: Routledge.
Ramazani, R. K. (1992) “Iran's Foreign Policy: Both North and South” The Middle East Journal 46, 3:  393-412.
Reuters (2015) “"Exclusive: Turkish Intelligence Helped Ship Arms to Syrian Islamist Rebel Areas” (21/5), available at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mideast-crisis-turkey-arms-idUSKBN0O61L220150521. (Last Access 9/21/2018)
Reuters (2017) “Turkish Erdoğan Calls Iraqi Kurdish Referendum Illegitimate,” (28/9), available at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mideast-crisis-kurds-referendum-erdog/turkeys-erdogan-calls-iraqi-kurdish-referendum-illegitimate-idUSKCN1C32YG. (Last Access 9/21/2018)  
Robins, Philip (2003) Suits and Uniforms: Turkish Foreign Policy Since the Cold War. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Rose, Gideon (1998) “Neoclassical Realism and Theories of Foreign Policy,” World Politics 51, 1: 144-172.
Rousseau, David L. (2007) “Identity, Power, and Threat Perception: A Cross-National Experimental Study,” Journal of Conflict Resolution 51, 5: 744-771.
Russell, James A. (2005)“Saudi Arabia in the 21st Century: A New Security Dilemma,” Middle East Policy, 12, 3: 64-78.
Russell, Richard L. (2004) Peering Over the Horizon: Arab Threat Perception and Security Reponses to a Nuclear-Ready Iran. Prepared for the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center
Safran, Nadav (1988) Saudi Arabia: The Ceaseless Quest for Security. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.  
Saikal, Amin (2020) “Iran: Aspirations and Constraints,” in Adham Saouli, ed., Unfulfilled Aspirations: Middle Power Politics in the Middle East. New York: Oxford University Press: 113-134.
Saouli, Adham (2020) “Introduction: Middle Powers in the Middle East,” in Adham Saouli, ed., Unfulfilled Aspirations: Middle Power Politics in the Middle East. New York: Oxford University Press: 1-10.
SIPRI (2018) SIPRI Fact Sheet: Trends in World Military Expenditure, 2017. Stockholm: International Peace Research Institute.
Steinberg, Guido (2014) Leading the Counter-Revolution: Saudi Arabia and the Arab Spring. SWP Research Paper. Berlin: German Institute for International and Security Affairs.  
Stirk, Peter (2005) “John Hertz: Realism and the Fragility of International Order,” Review of International Studies 31: 285-306.
Sylvest, Casper (2008) “John H. Herz and the Resurrection of Classical Realism,” International Relations 22, 4: 441–455.
Tang, Shiping (2009) “The Security Dilemma: A Conceptual Analysis,” Security Studies 18,3: 587-623.
Tansey, Oisin, Koehler, Kevin, and Schmotz, Alexander (2017) “Ties to the Rest: Autocratic Linkages and Regime Survival,” Comparative Political Studies 50, 9 :1221-1254.
Taremi, Kamran (2005) “Iranian Foreign Policy Towards Occupied Iraq, 2003-05,” Middle East Policy, 12, 4: 28-47.
Taşpinar, Ömer (2011) “The Rise of Turkish Gaullism: Getting Turkish-American Relations Right,” Insight Turkey 13, 1: 11-17.
Tezcur, Gunes Murat (2010) Muslim Reformers in Iran and Turkey: The Paradox of Moderation. Austin: University of Texas Press.
van den Berg, Willem (2017) “Saudi Arabia’s Strategic Stalemate – What Next?” CRU Policy Brief. Clingendael, Netherlands Institute of International Relations.
Walt, Stephen M (1996) Revolution and War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Waltz, Kenneth (1996) “International Politics Is Not Foreign Policy,” Security Studies 6, 1: 54-57.
Wehrey, Frederic (2013) The Forgotten Uprising in Eastern Saudi Arabia. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
Wendt, Alexander (1992) “Anarchy Is What Sates Make of It,” International Organization 46, 2: 391-425.
Wivel, Anders (2008) “Balancing against Threats or Bandwagoning with Power? Europe and the Transatlantic Relationship after the Cold War”, Cambridge Review of International Affairs 21, 3: 289-305.
Yehiav, Ayellet (2007) “The Anti-Iranian Front: Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan,” Middle East Review of International Affairs 11, 1: 6-9.